Hey Pauly, glad you’re digging into this one!
Based on your feedback — no chocolate mousse, no AP, but malted milk as the star — I reworked the original into two versions that should stay true to your intent but lean into the warm, creamy malted vibe you’re after.
Pauly’s Dream Cream – V1 (Nutty & Malty)
This version leans into hazelnut to replace the toastiness AP would’ve brought, while giving that warm backnote that plays great with malt.
Recipe:
Malted Milk (TFA) – 2.25%
Custard Cream (CAP) – 2.50%
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (TFA) – 4.00%
Hazelnut (FA or FW) – 0.75%
Brown Sugar (TFA) – 0.75%
Madagascar Vanilla (FA) – 0.50%
Super Sweet (CAP) – 0.50%
Total Flavour: 11.25%
Warm, creamy, with a subtle nutty body that gives it that “just roasted” vibe.
Pauly’s Dream Cream – V2 (White Chocolate Body)
If you’re looking for no nut, this one’s all about soft, milky richness with a smooth finish. White chocolate brings thickness and sweet creaminess without the cocoa punch.
Recipe:
Malted Milk (TFA) – 2.25%
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (TFA) – 4.00%
Custard Cream (CAP) – 2.50%
White Chocolate (INW or LB) – 1.50%
Brown Sugar (TFA) – 0.75%
Madagascar Vanilla (FA) – 0.50%
Super Sweet (CAP) – 0.50%
Total Flavour: 12%
It’s a rich malt milkshake with velvet cream notes. Think old-school soda fountain dessert.
Let either of these steep a good 5–7 days and let us know which version hits that old Brown Sugar vibe best. Once we’ve got a winner, we’ll brand it up proper. 

Cheers!