OK, aside from the un-burnt cigarette flavored juice I tried when I first vaped, I have never vaped a tobacco flavored juice. I’ve read a lot of threads about them, but never followed any closely.
I would like to try one, but I don’t want to buy a bunch of concentrates to build one, at least not first.
What I am looking for is a pipe tobacco flavor… Something sweet, earthy, vanilla noted… the kind I used to love smelling when Dad took us to the pipe tobacco stores when I was a kid.
I heard good things about Desert Ship HS but have no experience with it.
I personally detest Coumarin Pipe, it’s too herby for me.
Highway I liked but it is a long time ago, all I remember is that it is not sweet or vanilla.
The Latakia is very potent and IMO good as an additive but not a standalone.
I do like the Soho but IMO it is more of a bakery concentrate than a tobacco. It needs quite a high percentage for FA. It is sweet though, a bit nutty with caramel/vanilla notes.
I know nothing about the rest.
I have a somewhat different issue that I could use a little help with. My sister has just committed to try vaping again and is looking for a cigarette flavored tobacco with no sweetness. So that leaves RY4 our of the mix. I honestly don’t like tobacco flavors at all, so coming up with an idea that works for her is leaving me in the dark. I know I’ll need to buy new concentrates for this, but if anyone has a cigarette like recipe, I would be very appreciative.
I am not a tobacco flavour guy by any stretch but I have heard (never tried) FA Soho at 10% (yes that is a 10) plus INW dirty neutral base (stay low) for the ashy part may help you out.